Are we ready for Moonlighting?

Employment contracts and company policies may prohibit secondary employment that poses conflicts of interest or competes with the primary job. Breaching such clauses may lead to disciplinary action or termination. Government policy recommendations encompass legal considerations, encouraging employers to prohibit moonlighting in contracts and promoting flexible work arrangements to adapt to evolving employment dynamics. Employer strategies emphasize clear moonlighting policies, conflict of interest prevention, and competitive compensation to deter moonlighting. 

Conclusion:

Published in Free Press Journal (2022), it has the following conclusions: 

1) 61% of the respondents believed moonlighting to be unethical. Nonetheless, 73% of the respondents indulged in moonlighting. 

2) A survey conducted by a student mentioned that Employees go for moonlighting mainly because of Monetary gains. 

In the write-up, we explored various aspects of moonlighting in India through a detailed analysis. For many Indians, supplementary income through moonlighting remains crucial for meeting financial needs and supporting families. However, it also challenges employers regarding conflicts of interest and compliance with service-level expectations.

As remote and flexible work becomes more common, the prevalence of moonlighting may increase further. Clear policies will be pivotal for companies to balance employee needs with organizational priorities. Moonlighting underscores the evolving nature of work and calls for nuanced policy measures and adaptive workplace culture. With careful management, it holds the potential to contribute to India’s economic growth by empowering individuals and promoting entrepreneurship.

The simple and understandable dictionary meaning of ‘moonlighting’ is to have a second job, typically secretly at night, in addition to regular employment. Moonlighting can be referred to as the practice of holding a second job and working for another employer or engaging in employment outside of one’s primary job or after the predetermined working hours of first employment. 

The culture and term of moonlighting came into prominence in the West, where employees started looking for secondary jobs to have extra income, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic when work-from-home was the norm. The new and young working generation of Gen Z and the millennials how they take moonlighting were all billion-dollar questions. However, the basic question that remained unanswered was moonlighting at whose cost. 

Significance of moonlighting in the Indian context:

With respect to the Indian context, moonlighting possesses both positive and negative aspects to it. In terms of the Indian economy, it can be an excellent contributor to an individual’s wealth and the nation’s GDP. However, it can hamper productivity and result in conflicts of interest. 

Chairman of Indian ITgiant Wipro, Rashid Premji, fired over 300 employees for moonlighting and condemning the practices, saying it amounts to cheating. Since then, the moonlighting row has come into the limelight in the Indian industry. (India Today, 2022)

Shaonlee Bose, Founder and Managing Partner of White Ideas Media, opined that ‘blanket policies on moonlighting across industries and roles will not work.’ 

This write-up focuses on the aspect of moonlighting, especially in the Indian context, and what are the pros and cons related to it, along with the current scenario of moonlighting in today’s workplaces. 

Literature Review:

In the paper, ‘Impact of Moonlighting on Professional Institutes -A Study,’ Prof.Dr.M.A.Lahori and Prof. Dr. D.P.More have understood the interpretation of the Impact of ‘Moonlighting.’

Their findings throw light on the below questions:

The survey on ‘Impact of Moonlighting on Industries during and post COVID-19 Pandemic: Evidence from Pune, India’ by Dr. Sunetra Gaitonde, Upendra Lele, and Dr. Shagufta Sayeed, received 133 responses out of 17 from employers, and the remaining were from employees. The survey implies the following scores:

Pros and Cons of Moonlighting in the Indian Context:

Pros of Moonlighting:

1. 1. Supplemental income for individuals: 

Having several sources of income can offer financial stability and enhance the overall quality of life in a nation where income disparities are common and regional variations in the cost of living are notable. The extra money from moonlighting can be used for a variety of purposes, such as providing for a family, saving for future objectives, or just enjoying a higher standard of living.

2. 2. Skill diversification and development:

Beyond financial considerations, moonlighting also offers valuable opportunities for skill development and career advancement. Many individuals take on side gigs or freelance work to acquire new skills or hone existing ones. This continuous learning and upskilling enhance employability, empower individuals to pursue new career paths and explore diverse opportunities in India’s rapidly evolving job market.

3. 3. Increased job satisfaction and engagement:

Moreover, moonlighting can serve as a form of job security in an uncertain economic climate. By diversifying their income streams through moonlighting, individuals can mitigate the risks associated with unemployment or underemployment, safeguarding their financial well-being and maintaining stability in their professional lives.

4. 4. Entrepreneurial Experience:

Moonlighting offers a valuable entrepreneurial experience for aspiring business owners and freelancers. Many individuals in India use moonlighting as a stepping stone to entrepreneurship, testing business ideas, building a client base, and gaining valuable insights into market dynamics while still holding onto the security of their primary job. This gradual transition allows entrepreneurs to minimize risk, validate their business concepts, and eventually scale their ventures into full-time pursuits, contributing to India’s vibrant startup ecosystem.

5. 5. Diversification of income

Moonlighting provides unparalleled networking opportunities, enabling individuals to expand their professional connections and forge valuable relationships within their industries. Whether it’s collaborating with clients, networking with fellow freelancers, or attending industry events and conferences, moonlighting exposes individuals to diverse perspectives, expertise, and opportunities for collaboration and career advancement.

Cons of Moonlighting:

1. 1. Conflict of Interest: 

Moonlighting can lead to conflicts of interest, as employees may use their primary employer’s resources, time, or intellectual property for their secondary employment.

2. 2. Decreased Productivity: 

Employees who moonlight are 15% more likely to show signs of exhaustion and decreased efficiency at their primary jobs.

3. 3. Legal and Contractual Implications: 

Moonlighting may violate employment contracts, confidentiality agreements, and non-compete clauses.

4. 4. Risk of Data Breach and Leakage: 

Employees may inadvertently share sensitive information or use company resources for their secondary employment, posing a risk to data security.

5. 5. Negative Impact on Employee Engagement: 

Moonlighting can lead to employee disengagement, as they may prioritize their secondary employment over their primary job.

6. 6. Time Commitment: 

Doing a second job can consume a lot of one’s time and prevent him/her from having enough time for his/her family, friends, and interests, among other vital elements of his/her life. 

7. 7. Burnout: 

Several occupations can be intellectually and physically draining, which raises the risk of burnout.

Legal Context:

1. 1. Indian Contract Act: Section 27 of the Indian Contract Act states that any agreement that restrains a person from exercising a lawful trade or business is void, but this does not apply to employment contracts.

1. 1. Supreme Court Rulings: The Indian Supreme Court has established that moonlighting clauses are enforceable after the employment contract has ended.

1. 1. Industry-Specific Regulations: The Industrial Employment (Standing Orders) Rules 1946 and the Industrial Relations Code permit employees to take up extra assignments at their employer’s discretion.

Detailed Analysis of Moonlighting in the Indian Context:

Overview of Moonlighting Trends in India:

1. 1. Factories Act, 1948 (Section 60): This act restricts factory workers from having multiple jobs beyond their regular working hours

1. 1. Delhi Shops and Establishments Act, 1954 (Section 9) limits employees from working in multiple establishments beyond legal working hours.

On the other hand, there are multiple Indian IT firms and app-based platforms that are positive about moonlighting.

1. 1. Cred: This fintech unicorn encourages side hustles among its employees.

1. 1. Swiggy: recently introduced an industry-first “Moonlighting policy.” Under this policy, employees can work on other projects after their regular working hours as long as it does not impact their productivity or conflict with Swiggy’s business interests.

Statistical data on the prevalence of moonlighting:

In a 2022 Free Press Journal survey of 950 employees (540 from IT, 325 from Finance, 85 from Education), it was discovered that 73% of employees indulge in moonlighting in India, and 61% say it is unethical.

Following were the industry-wide numbers of employees engaged in moonlighting and an insight into how COVID-19 normalized the practice across all. 

Gig-economy gained traction, and with additional time on hand, people developed skills and opened up revenue-generation opportunities on the side.

Analysis of moonlighting patterns among different demographics: 

Impact on Different Demographics:

1. 1. IT Sector: 43% of IT employees find moonlighting favorable.

1. 1. Millennials and Gen Z: 64% of full-time millennial workers want to opt for the gig economy, and 37% are likely to switch employers if they are not allowed to moonlight.

1. 1. Industries with High Unemployment: Moonlighting is more prevalent in industries with high unemployment, such as manufacturing and healthcare, where employees may moonlight to make ends meet.

Discussion of Factors Influencing Moonlighting:

1. 1. The Economic Score:

The opening bars are often dictated by the economic realities of income disparities. For those facing stagnant wages, rising costs of living, or unexpected bills, moonlighting becomes a necessity, a financial lifeline supplementing their primary income. Additionally, the job market’s volatility plays its part. In times of high unemployment or limited opportunities, individuals may see moonlighting as a safety net, offering stability and mitigating the risk of relying solely on one job.

2. 2. The Sociocultural Harmony:

However, the symphony extends beyond financial needs. Work-life balance plays a delicate counterpoint. While some find financial solace in moonlighting, others struggle to harmonize their personal lives with the demands of multiple jobs. Cultural attitudes also offer contrasting melodies. In some cultures, moonlighting is a sign of ambition and resourcefulness, while others view it as a symptom of instability or lack of commitment to the primary job. 

3. 3. The Legal and Regulatory Rhythm:

The legal and regulatory framework sets the overall tempo for moonlighting practices. Government policies on overtime pay, working hours, and restrictions on secondary employment act as guiding principles. These policies determine the feasibility and legality of taking on a second job. 

Recommendations:

In India, it has been established through court rulings that employers hold the right to terminate employees who engage in moonlighting. To steer clear of disciplinary measures, it is recommended that employees seek permission for any secondary employment and clearly outline the permissible activities that will be carried out outside of working hours. Companies should consider implementing non-compete clauses, intellectual property protection, and confidentiality agreements in employment contracts to safeguard their interests. It is critical to clarify roles and exclusivity, which will help ensure compliance and prevent misconduct. To address misconduct and establish clear employment conditions, it is necessary to have robust contracts and HR regulations in place.

While Indian laws lack a precise definition, specific regulations address dual employment to some extent. According to the Factories Act of 1948 and the Occupational Safety, Health, and Working Conditions (OSH) Code, employees are generally prohibited from working in a factory or mine on a day they have already worked in another factory or mine, aiming to safeguard worker health and prevent overwork.

Bibliography (APA)

1. 1. Desk, F. E., & Desk, F. E. (2022, November 14). 73% of employees indulge in moonlighting in India, and 61% say it is unethical. Study. Free Press Journal. Retrieved from https://www.freepressjournal.in

1. 1. (PDF) moonlighting as a growing phenomenon: A case study of a … Available at: Link

1. 1. Impact of moonlighting on industries during and post covid … Available at: Link

1. 1. Tojdel. Available at: Link

1. 1. Wipro chief who fired 300 employees for ‘moonlighting’ on receiving end of ‘hate mails’ (2022a) India Today. Available at: Link

1. 1. IRMBR Journal. Available at: https://irmbrjouyrnal.com/papers/1575429448.pdf (Accessed: 18 February 2024). 

1. 1. A study of impact of moonlighting practices on job … Available at: https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1210332.pdf